Thursday, September 10, 2015

Someone at a Distance, by Dorothy Whipple

This book was my introduction to Dorothy Whipple.  She is an author I have learned about only recently, from some of my favorite bloggers (including Anbolyn, Jane, and JoAnn).  So I was very pleased when I saw a Persephone edition of this on the library sale cart - for all of $1.

I think the editors did a neat job of summing up the plot in their back-cover blurb:
Someone at a Distance has a deceptively simple plot about a deceived wife and a foolish husband.  Avery North has been contentedly married to Ellen for twenty years, they have two children and live in the rural commuter belt outside London; when his mother advertises for a companion, the French girl who arrives sets her sights on Avery and callously threatens the happy marriage.  Throughout the book Ellen and Avery are so realistically described that it is almost painful to read: this is a deeply involving and perceptive novel by the literary heir to Mrs Gaskell.

Actually, there's a slight inaccuracy there: Mrs. North doesn't advertise but answers an advertisement, in the personal column of The Times: "Young Frenchwoman desires to spend July, August in English home. French conversation. Light domestic duties." 

We are introduced to the Frenchwoman, Louise Lannier, in the next chapter, as she announces her new post to her parents.  We learn something about her life in her small provincial town, and why she wants to leave it behind for England.  As the story develops, it moves back and forth between France and England, between Louise and Mrs. North, Ellen and Avery and their children.  Eventually Louise comes to stay with Ellen and Avery, and it's then that the trouble begins.

I liked Ellen very much from the start, so my sympathies were with her throughout the story.  She is a good person, a loving wife and mother, busy in the home and expressing her love in domestic cares.  Like many middle-class women after the Second World War, she doesn't have help in the home, so she's always rushing around, trying to do too much, but happy in it.  I also liked Anne, their daughter, who lives for school holidays and her horse Roma.  I felt much sympathy for Monsieur and Madame Lannier, who can never do anything right for their difficult daughter but love her all the same.  And there is a little black and white cat, who first appears galloping to meet Avery and Ellen as they drive up to their home.  Cats who gallop around cars often come to a bad end, and as with the rabbits in Monica Dickens' The Fancy, I was always subconsciously waiting for something awful to happen to little Moppet.  (Spoiler alert: nothing does.)  The headmistress at Anne's school has a cat who lolls around in her study, so I think that Dorothy Whipple may have been a cat person.

More serious spoilers follow:

My only quibble with this book is its ending - specifically, the last two pages.  Up til then, I thought it a perfect ending.  Ellen has survived Avery leaving her for Louise, and their eventual divorce.  She has found a new home, with room for Anne and her son Hugh - not to mention Moppet and Roma.  She has friends, and satisfying work.  She has regained her balance and her strength.  The Avery turns up unexpectedly, with Louise, whom he married after the divorce though he doesn't love or even like her.  Ellen realizes that he is miserable with Louise, that he will leave her and return to Ellen, when their children are grown and gone - and she will wait for him.  I was sorry to read that "The painfully achieved repairs to her life were all broken down . . . Now she must start again and it all seemed chaotic and impossible."  I wanted her choose that repaired, new life.  "Creeping into her heart was the realisation that, although she could not be with him, Avery was restored to her."  She chooses that old love instead, and I found that an unsatisfactory ending - but maybe a realistic one.

Now that I've met Dorothy Whipple, I don't want to wait for copies of her books to turn up (particularly when Persephones are so rare in Houston bookstores new or used).  I have already ordered The Priory and They Were Sisters (which I've been anxious to read).  It was only the shipping costs - and a faint protest from my TBR conscience - that kept me from adding High Wages and Greenbanks to the order.

11 comments:

  1. I felt the same way about the ending. It bothered me that she was going to disrupt her new life. I do enjoy Dorothy Whipple though. I have Because of the Lockwoods on my shelf waiting to be read. I have never commented before but I just wanted to say that I really enjoy your reviews.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm so glad you did, Jennifer - it's nice to meet you! I've just been over visiting your blog, and I see we have similar tastes in books :) I will keep Because of the Lockwoods in mind for my next Persephone order.

      Delete
  2. I'm so glad you enjoyed Dorothy Whipple! Someone at a Distance is my favorite so far, but They Were Sisters is wonderful, too. The Priory is waiting on my shelf.

    A couple quotes from this book still stick out in my mind... both toward the end, I think.
    "These women were old, time had softened them, they had learned something from loss, helplessness, loneliness; they knew almost anything can happen to anybody. They were kinder than when they were young."


    "Life is like a sea, sometimes you are in the trough of a wave, sometimes on the crest. When you are in the trough, you wait for the crest, and always, trough or crest, a mysterious tide bears you forward to an unseen, but certain shore."

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. And I forgot to mention that I was bothered by that ending, too

      Delete
    2. Those quotes struck me as well. I love the old ladies at the home, and I was so happy that Ellen was going to be there (and Miss Daley) to enjoy their company again - but also help them.

      It was your review of They Were Sisters that put it high on my reading list - though I remember it isn't a happy story.

      Delete
  3. I love it when I find a "new" author to read ... and so nice that you were able to get this book for only $1! Hope you enjoy her other books as much. :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I've discovered so many wonderful new-to-me authors through blogging. Now I just need to figure out how to squeeze another bookshelf into my apartment :)

      Delete
  4. This is such a good book, but yes I agree the ending was a tiny letdown. And I didn't expect it - I thought Ellen would go on and find contentment on her own. I did find Louise to be a pretty fascinating character and I loved the scenes of her with her family in France. This is probably my third favorite Whipple of the ones I've read, behind They Were Sisters and Greenbanks.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I am definitely putting Greenbanks on the list for another Persephone order! I did find Louise an interesting character, and I felt some sympathy for her. She was so strong and determined!

    ReplyDelete
  6. You've greatly relieved my mind with the cat spoiler - I feel that I can now pick this off my shelf (where it has been looking at me for far too long) without any worries at all. (Except for wishing that my copy had been $1, of course!)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I absolutely want to know about any animal-related traumas before I start a book.

      Even better than the low, low price was the lack of shipping fees - the main reason I won't be ordering in bulk from Persephone.

      Delete

Thank you for taking the time to read, and to comment. I always enjoy hearing different points of view about the books I am reading, even if we disagree!